I once asked the Copyblogger community to name their biggest writing problems. From the many responses, a pattern about the... The post The 5-Step Writing Process That Solves 3 Painful Problems appeared first on Copyblogger. via Copyblogger https://ift.tt/RcUL1ds
0 Comments
Google Analytics 4 (GA4) rebuilt the platform from the ground up with a new central focus on events, enhancing users’ ability to customize tracking for specific actions across websites and apps. To set up GA4 properly, you should think through the events that make sense to track for your site. This article covers the events you can track by default and how to set up custom events, along with suggested use cases for each. Built-in eventsOut of the box, GA4 includes events for several categories that can be automatically collected, including the following as of the time of this article. Page viewThe page_view event fires whenever a page is loaded or the browser history state changes. This can’t be disabled. Scroll trackingThe scroll event fires when a user scrolls 90% of the way through a page. Outbound click trackingThe click event only fires for clicks leading to separate domains. Site searchThis tracks internal search activity if you have the option included on your site. The view_search_results event fires every time someone completes a search. The search_term parameter will include the actual term that was searched. Form interactionThis fires form_start at the start of an interaction with a form (i.e., the user clicks inside a text field) and when the form is submitted (form_submit). You can fire additional parameters to show form_id, form_name, and form_destination to delineate interactions with specific forms. Video engagementVideo engagement tracks starts (video_start), completions (video_complete), and watch duration (video_progress) for embedded videos. Parameters within the events can indicate the specific percentage or timestamp within the video when an action occurs and the video title and URL, regardless of its visibility on the page. File downloadsThis fires the file_download event for clicks leading to several common file formats, such as text documents, spreadsheets, presentations, executable files, compressed files, video, and audio Note that, apart from page views, you need to manually enable these events via Enhanced Event Measurement for them to fire. To do so, from within the Admin section of your GA4 account, go to Data Streams under your GA4 property and select the stream you’re working from. From here, you’ll see the Enhanced measurement option near the top. Toggle the switch on and select the gear to see the options for measuring specific events. You can then toggle on all the events you’d like to include. Of course, these built-in events have limitations and barely scratch the surface of GA4’s capabilities. Before discussing other uses for events, let’s cover how you can create new events. Creating custom eventsFrom within the Admin section for your GA4 property, navigate to Events. You'll see a Create event button, which you can click to begin the process. Next, you'll see a Create event screen from which you can click the Create button. From here, you can add the event name and customize any parameters to pass additional information through to Google Analytics. If you want to use an event as a conversion, you'll see a Mark as conversion option next to existing events listed in the Events section. Toggle this to include the event in the Conversions report for the future and lump it together with metrics such as Conversion and Conversion Rate when creating custom explorations. Let's look at a few practical uses for custom events on your website or app. Internal click trackingWhile GA4 records events for outbound clicks by default, internal clicks leading to the same domain or domains included in cross-domain measurement are not tracked. However, you may want to track these clicks to answer questions such as:
Using Google Tag Manager, you can set up an event to target a click on a specific element within your site. While the exact approach may vary depending on the site, you could set up a trigger based on an HTML ID, a link URL, object text, or other criteria to ensure you're picking up on the correct click. Logged-in activityIf applicable to your site, you can fire a sign_up event when users register or login when current users log into their accounts. This tracking could help answer questions such as:
Beyond setting up these events, explore setting up user ID tracking, in which you assign a unique ID to each individual and can connect future sessions to the same user when they log in down the road. Ecommerce eventsFor ecommerce sites, be sure to incorporate tracking for cart, checkout, and purchase-related activities. GA4 recommends the following events which are relevant for common ecommerce actions you'd want to record:
App engagementGA4 can track several events related to app interactions, such as when users:
These examples and others are automatically collected, but additional recommended events can be included, depending on the type of app. For instance, a game may include tutorials to teach new users how to play. You can fire events for people working their way through the tutorial, showing how many individuals start the process and how many finish without dropping out. Other in-game events can track starting/ending levels, spending virtual currency, unlocking achievements, and posting scores. Start creating eventsThis is just an initial list of potential events to create for your site or app, but the possibilities are endless for tracking your particular setup. Consider the user actions crucial to your business or clients and how you can correlate events with these activities. The sooner you gather historical events, the more robust data you'll have for future analysis. The post Event tracking in Google Analytics 4: What marketers need to know appeared first on Search Engine Land. via Search Engine Land https://ift.tt/afktQ6n Let’s set the record straight. Google News optimization is not only for news sites. Any website which regularly invests in timely content can reach engaged audiences and drive quality traffic with a solid Google News SEO strategy. Google News-driven results send over 24 billion clicks per month to publishers. Here’s how to claim your share. Google News aggregates and amplifies story exposureGoogle News is an aggregator that offers somewhat newsworthy local and international stories from numerous sources, categorizing content into topics. I say “somewhat newsworthy” because what Google defines as “news” is now lax. The publisher no longer needs to be a dedicated news site. You can get in with your blog if you regularly produce high-quality, original and timely content. You may get in without knowing it, as Google automatically considers any content in its index that complies with Google News content policies for inclusion. Ranking in Google News can be a game-changer for content visibility. However, audience targeting and reach can vary greatly depending on the placement. Partnership placementsThe Google News Showcase is a content licensing program in which Google pays participating publishers to curate their best content. It’s unique within Google News products because the publisher’s editorial team selects which stories to show readers. This selection is displayed in Google Discover and across Google News surfaces in a Sources panel. Personalized placementsGoogle personalizes content for each individual user based on their interests, sources, locations and past activity on Google Search and YouTube. This algorithm dictates what is shown on:
It can deliver a highly engaged audience if your coverage matches the user’s topics of interest. Location-driven placementsFor videos, Google News offers placements in:
Google News articles also have a chance to show:
However, the ultimate prize is securing a spot in the top stories carousel within universal search. This will also show if you ask Google Assistant news-driven queries such as “What’s the news?” None of these placements are personalized. Everyone of a qualifying age who shares the same region, language and location settings sees the same content. For this reason, non-personalized placements have a higher impact potential. Those within universal search can also offer an easier route to display for highly competitive search terms than attempting to rank position one. So with all that potential visibility on the line, what should you do to appeal to the Google News algorithms? It’s not as simple as a few bullet pointsThe bullet points on the “Ranking within Google News” guidelines are too simplistic and offer little tactical guidance. Even though Google does flesh them out in the News Initiative documentation, the added value is minimal. However, the documents clarify that much of the ranking system used in Google News is shared with that of Google Search. For example, with usability. This is all about clean, well-structured, cross-browser and cross-device compatible code that delivers on core web vitals. Now that Google News no longer requires AMP for the top stories carousel, usability optimization for Google News and Google Search is essentially the same. From here on, let’s assume that any point shared by both the Google News and Search algorithms is a given, and instead concentrate on specific SEO tactics for Google News that go beyond what you’re already doing for Google Search. Branding essentials for Google News SEOWhen it comes to the Google News algorithm, the conventional signals of relevance and popularity take a backseat to source authoritativeness. Think “E-E-A-T to the max” and curate credibility with these four tactics. Establish a strong presence in Google Publisher CenterIt’s not required to submit your site in Google Publisher Center, but it offers clear benefits:
To control the order of articles on your page in Google News, submit content as a feed rather than a section URL. Highlight author expertiseInclude a byline linked to the author’s page, or at least an author box, in every article submitted to Google News. The content must work toward establishing expertise and being recognized as an authority in their field. Ensure bios include:
For a real competitive advantage, collaborate with your key editorial team members to have them entered into the Google Knowledge Graph. Being associated with Google-acknowledged contributors enhances your publication’s credibility and reinforces Google’s trust in the value of your content. Provide newsroom transparencyBuild trust through an About page. This should include:
Invest in a strong social media presenceThe impact of social media signals on Google News rankings is contentious. But at the very least, brands aiming to gain traction in Google News should invest in regular tweeting to become eligible for the “From Twitter” section in “Full coverage” reports and the Twitter carousel in universal search, which appears on approximately 35% of all U.S. news related queries according to NewzDash. Technical essentials for Google News visibilityWhile Google News may include your article or video content without you doing any specific optimizations, the only way to see the channel’s full potential is by having the technical basics of Google News SEO in place. This involves four key actions. Entice Googlebot to crawl fasterLike any Google surface, your content can not be indexed by Google News without first being crawled. But speedy crawling is even more critical in Google News as it works off a short-term index and heavily biases fresh content. Making indexing speed paramount to success. In addition to crawl optimization fundamentals, get indexed fast by:
Exceed image expectationsImages are a key driver of click-through rate (CTR) from Google News. On news surfaces, Google may show various sizes of thumbnails or, in some cases, no image due to the article’s available image aspect ratios and resolutions. If the article’s image is subpar, it won’t qualify for all positions. As such, it is essential for news content to contain at least one image that meets the requirements of:
To avoid being limited by image quality and outperform competitors, work toward the following:
Technology can aid certain requirements, such as automated cropping to the additional aspect ratios and warning messages for non-compatible formats, but not the actual content of the image. Don’t allow your article to get lost in a sea of sameness. A standout image can compel a reader to click on your story over a competitor’s, resulting in Google News algorithms driving more visibility for that story and other stories. Ultimately, you must train your editorial teams on the “why” behind image requirements for Google News SEO because it impacts visibility in Google News and beyond (i.e., Discover, universal search and many other niche ecosystem touchpoints). Eliminate any date confusionGoogle states they don’t “depend on a single date factor because all factors can be prone to issues.” Leave no room for interpretation. Show a single, user-visible date and label it appropriately with text like “Published” or “Last updated.” Do this on a dateline in between the headline and the article text in a clear format. 07/03/2023 could be read as either March 7th or July 3rd, depending on your location. 7th March 2023 or Jul 3, 2023, on the other hand, leave no ambiguity. Minimize the presence of other dates on the page. Although it may be unavoidable within the article body, you control it in surrounding elements, such as not including the publication date of related articles. And as a final fallback, add “datePublished” or “dateModified” structured data, including the date and time. Be mindful of using the correct time zone and take daylight saving time into account. News-specific structured dataUse But don’t stop there. Additionally, as appropriate, add markup for:
Content essentials for Google News rankingsOnce you have the branding and technical fundamentals, take it to the next level with Google News content optimization techniques. Consistent topic coverageWhile reporting on news as it happens is essential, effective Google News optimization requires planning news stories into your editorial calendar. Leveraging relevant trending topics allows you to win visibility on news-related search terms that trigger the "Top stories" carousel. As such, keyword research remains critical. Google Trends is an excellent resource beyond the trending now section. In explore, select the "News search" option to identify topics with consistent news interest, such as celebrity names, or when predictable topics, such as annual events, will take off. Plan continuous coverage of the topics for as long as relevant. For breaking news stories, this means steadily publishing new, relevant information at a cadence that matches the story. For topics with predictable longevity, this means publishing or refreshing an article every few days during that period. This topical expansion can include news reports, interviews, opinion pieces, data journalism, photojournalism, live coverage, etc. Consistently plan ways to explore fresh angles. Resource constraints? Syndicated reportage is preferable to no coverage. Google asks for originality and promises to feature the publication that broke the story, but analysis highlights how freshness often wins over originality. Utilizing indexable syndicated content can drive significant organic sessions, but it should supplement original content, not replace it entirely. And remember, blindly chasing trending topics isn't a solid strategy. Evaluate its relevance to your editorial goals before investing resources. Because more than ever, news publishers are restricted by the need for E-E-A-T. A publication will typically only achieve top stories visibility for topics that they regularly cover. For example, ESPN is an authority in sports, but if they publish on an unrelated technology trend, they will not have the topical authority to be seen in Google News. Focus on freshnessGoogle states:
Yet, XML sitemaps are limited to the last 48 hours. A quick sampling on Google News surfaces will often be heavily biased to under 10 hours in the non-personalized and two days or under in the personalized placements. It's clear: the more recent the content, the higher chance of it being surfaced. So when you see a piece of content bringing in significant sessions start to drop off, refresh it by doing a substantial update to the content. This could include adding fresh text, rewriting key elements (i.e., the title or subheading) or swapping out images or videos. To get the page recrawled quickly, ensure the refresh triggers an update to the publication date on page and the last mod date in XML sitemaps and link the story from a prominent location such as the homepage or category page. If you don't regain traction through republishing but know the user interest in the topic remains trending, publish a new article from a different angle to appeal to Google News's desire for diversity of content. But don't be fooled. Freshness is not only about the publication date of an individual piece of content. They also factor in the overall brand. This is evidenced by numerous comments directly from Google:
So regular, relevant publishing is key. Headlines matterWhile Search results often display the As such, it's vital to use relevant, entity-focused keywords in the headline and convey as much of the story as possible. Essentially, treat your on-site article or YouTube video headline similar to how you would a title tag – knowing they don't need to exactly match to rank, but there should be a strong correlation. Google was uncharacteristically specific on headline requirements:
I say "was" because, in January, they removed the 110-character limit for the headline property in the
It's likely the best practice guideline has been forgotten in the update. Witty puns or lengthy lead-in style headlines that work well offline will only confuse search engines that rely heavily on headlines to determine ranking. They are also less likely to win the click when directly competing for the user's attention on a surface like Google News. Focus on making headlines clear and compelling, using the active voice and present tense to increase CTR. Understand the impact of Google News optimizationJust submitted a publication? Don't expect an immediate impact. Google News takes up to four weeks to review content after your first submission. Once you're in, start by confirming how many URLs submitted to Google News are crawled and indexed from an article and video perspective. This data is available in the indexing reports when you filter to your Google News sitemap. When you then move on to try to understand how that content is performing in Google News, you hit challenges. Google doesn't report its impact under clear line items but splits reporting over multiple sources or includes it in nondescript referrers and many other touchpoints. As such, Google News surfaces don't receive as much credit as they deserve. Nevertheless, use your data to understand topic coverage and hone your strategy. Key takeawayDon't try to be everything to everyone. Focus on your editorial specialties to establish E-E-A-T. Put in place a strong technical foundation, then strategically publish on relevant trending topics to leverage the vast visibility of Google News. The post How to master Google News optimization to boost content visibility and traffic appeared first on Search Engine Land. via Search Engine Land https://ift.tt/RpzXyaD One of the best things about starting your own business is that you can set it up to reflect your values. As a leader, you set the stage for:
Our mission is centered on a fierce commitment to our values and passion for inspiring others. We are committed to earning the trust of our colleagues, communities, and clients by serving them authentically, graciously and humbly. Generosity is so central to who we are that we recently started a nonprofit. It’s very different than many agencies that focus on creativity and “the work” in their purpose or mission statements – we want to be known for who we are more than what we do. Want to build your own values-based agency? Here’s how to ensure the values you set are infused within your organization. Behavioral interviewing paired with insightsA solid values-based agency starts with hiring the right people and asking them the right questions. My team asks questions about the candidate’s aptitude, abilities, and client management skills. As the person ultimately responsible for culture, I like to ask questions that give me a sense of who the person is. These include: “Have you ever been asked to do something that went against your sense of ethics?” and “What’s a common misconception about you?”
Protecting our values and shared culture means thinking more broadly than just who the prospective employee is. New hires must share the team’s values, complement our existing skillset and enhance the overall team and client experience. In other words, we want people who can elevate culture while adding new skills to the team. Having an infinite mindsetShort-term – or finite – thinking can lead people to compromise values they may otherwise hold strongly. As an agency leader, you must sometimes focus on short-term needs, like ensuring you have enough money for payroll. But if you’re the type of finite leader who hires and fires based on short-term needs, you’ll build a different culture than you might intend. Ethical fading, or losing sight of ethical connotations of decisions, can creep in when people are only focused on the near term. Use an infinite mindset whenever possible to build a strong, high-performing, values-based agency. An infinite mindset means focusing on a greater purpose and acknowledging that the goal of a business is to keep playing the game. The priority is building high-trust teams, understanding that you’ll often need to flex and adapt to stay in business, and respecting your worthy rivals. Agencies may exhibit finite thinking when they lay people off quickly after losing a client or are solely focused on selling the agency. Investing in leadership training and developmentMost agencies ensure their people are great marketers and are up to speed on the latest tactics. That’s a given and should certainly be part of the marketing training curriculum. However, investing in leadership training and development at all levels helps ensure your team knows what you truly value. As an agency leader, I see my role as developing the next generation of great leaders, not just the next generation of great marketers. Now that you know how to ensure values are engrained within your organization, how do you ensure that you're driving and getting the results for your agency by leading with values? It comes through receiving benefits in three key areas. 1. Employee retentionDigital marketers have a lot of choices regarding where to work. While the old perks like pool tables or happy hours used to matter, remote work has changed what drives employee satisfaction and retention. The ability to leave home to pick up kids and perform some work off-hours. Believing in the company's values and having systems that allow employees to feel connected to their colleagues. These are all important. Employee turnover is disruptive both to the company and its clients. Our turnover is less than half of the norm. I attribute this to leading our people with clarity of our values and setting them up as best as possible to lean into them. Are we perfect? No. But with values and purpose as a focus, it helps keep employees around longer than the norm. The alignment of values is key to building a mutual foundation of trust between employees and an agency. It also helps make bonding easier among employees. 2. Client satisfactionClients appreciate values such as transparency, humility, and gratitude. Building trusted relationships and managing their accounts by a strong values-based group leads to higher client satisfaction and retention. Of course, the marketers must be managing accounts well – that's table stakes. Building deep relationships builds a shared commitment and vision. It helps create an "us" mentality with the client and agency as a team, as opposed to the common "them" or "vendor" relationship. One other benefit of building deep relationships? As your client partners leave for other companies, there's a good chance they will bring you. 3. Increased innovationValues-led organizations tend to create psychological safety. This means a safe environment exists for individuals to share their thoughts and ideas with leaders. Innovation must not be limited to new strategies and tactics – it can be new processes or feedback on what types of services the agency should start or stop offering. Innovation can be team-based, as well. This can lead to employees being heard and feeling valued, something which will also play into retention I hope that these views on building a strong values-based culture help you strengthen your agency to drive the results you seek. The post How to build a values-based agency that drives results appeared first on Search Engine Land. via Search Engine Land https://ift.tt/GvA0XPc Microsoft is exploring ways to share ad revenue it generates through the new Bing, Bing Chat, with select publishers. Bing Chat has had ads since it launched on February 7th. Now, Microsoft says it will look to “share the ad revenue with partners whose content contributed to the chat response.” What’s new. “We’re also exploring placing ads in the chat experience to share the ad revenue with partners whose content contributed to the chat response,” Microsoft vice president Yusuf Mehdi wrote. “We recently met with some of our partners to begin exploring ideas and to get feedback on how we can continue to distribute content in a way that is meaningful in traffic and revenue for our partners,” he added. Microsoft Start partners. This seems to be something that Microsoft is conducting through its Microsoft Start partners program. “For our Microsoft Start partners, placing a rich caption of Microsoft Start licensed content beside the chat answer helping to drive more user engagement with the content on Microsoft Start where we share the ad revenue with the partner,” Yusuf Mehdi added. Microsoft introduced Microsoft Start in 2021. It is a personalized news feed that aggregates content from about 7500 participating “premium publishers.” Start is available via desktop and mobile devices. Microsoft gets publishers. Microsoft acknowledges the value of publishers in this post. “The Internet works because of an important ecosystem which starts with publishers creating great content which drives traffic and interest by people to consume that content, and then ultimately advertisers that want to reach people in a high quality and targeted environment,” Mehdi wrote. Without publishers, search and chat would not function as well and Microsoft wants to make sure that at least some publishers are compensated so they can continue to generate quality content. “For the most part this dynamic has worked well as publishers get paid for their content through advertising which enables people to access the content for free,” he added. Ads in Bing Chat. Ads in Bing Chat are not new. There are many reports claiming Bing Chat has recently added ads. That is incorrect, in fact, on February 7th, Microsoft demonstrated ads in Bing Chat and we even reported about meetings with advertisers and brands about the future of ads in Bing Chat. Here are some of those ad formats (more details from Search Engine Roundtable here). Click to enlarge any of these images: Why we care. While Google Bard seems to have turned a blind eye to publishers, Microsoft is looking for ways to not just link and drive traffic to publishers but also help them earn revenue from the responses provided by Bing Chat. It is nice to see one big search engine outwardly talking about compensating publishers for the answers it generates through the content produced by hard-working publishers. That said, the term “premium publishers” concerns us. It’s nice that ABC News, The Wall Street Journal, New York Times, HufffPost, CNN and 7500 other publishers may get paid, but there are nearly 2 billion websites producing content on the internet. As a percentage, 7500 isn’t even detectable. Additional reporting on this story from Chris Elwell. The post Microsoft explores sharing Bing Chat ad revenue with publishers appeared first on Search Engine Land. via Search Engine Land https://ift.tt/ksq8HPD Search marketers earn anywhere from $60,000 to $220,000 in annual compensation (salary and bonuses), on average, according to a new Search Engine Land survey. Why we care. Search marketing is an attractive and satisfying career choice that can, over time, become increasingly lucrative. The keys to earning that higher compensation? Seniority, role and the size of the company or organization you work for. By the numbers. VP and C-level positions earn the most – $220,613 in annual compensation, on average. Directors and senior directors earn $122,760; managers $87,688; and staff $60,866, all on average.
Salaries vary greatly within roles. Averages sometimes can be misleading. So let’s break that down a bit further to get a more nuanced view:
Why the variance? Location is one big reason (see our Methodology section below). But there are more factors, such as the size of the organization and years of experience. Case in point. Respondents who work at the largest companies get greater compensation. Search marketers at organizations with more than 10,000 employees earned $169,988, on average.
Compensation increases with seniority. Years of experience typically translate into higher compensation. The first jump in salary comes around year six or seven (~$66,000 to ~$88,000), and the second salary jump comes when you reach year 10 (~$88,000 to ~$120,000), our data showed: Graduate degrees don’t factor in compensation. Of the 276 respondents who answered this question, 66% said they did not have a graduate degree and earned $95,039, on average. Meanwhile, 16% reported having a graduate degree in business, but their average salary was only slightly higher at $98,988, on average.
Meanwhile, more than 90% of search marketers have an undergraduate degree. 64% work at brands; 32% at agencies. Nearly two-thirds of respondents worked at brands.
The majority (72%) of respondents said their role was digital marketing. Of the 11% who answered “other,” more than half had “SEO” in their title. Methodology. We surveyed 510 marketers between Jan. 11 to 23; 413 of those provided salary information. Invitations to take the survey were amplified on and by Search Engine Land. Nearly 67% of the 510 respondents live in North America; 20% live in Western Europe. The conclusions in this report are limited to responses from those individuals only. Others were excluded due to the limited number. The survey had more than 20 questions related to career roles, salary, technology, job satisfaction and challenges/frustrations. Respondents were given the opportunity to reveal their age and gender. More to come. Over the next two days, we’ll look at the differences in salaries and careers of women and men, and also dig deeper into roles and responsibilities. The post 2023 Salary & Career guide: How much search marketers make appeared first on Search Engine Land. via Search Engine Land https://ift.tt/fe0LZrj Millennials and Gen Zers are set to dominate B2B buying committees this year, so keeping up with them is a must. More than knowing the latest trends, we must continually assess:
On the flip side, all marketers know many platforms today are overcrowded with advertisers. This is an uphill battle for B2B marketers competing against the often punchier and eye-grabbing creative for B2C brands. Enter Reddit Ads. B2B marketers can leverage Reddit to stand out from the crowd and stay in front of target audiences. This article will outline tactical recommendations if you want to test the platform for the first time or need help to improve current campaigns. 1. Conversation placement ads > standard adsWhy use standard promoted ads when you can engage prospects when they are the most engaged? Conversation placement ads, positioned immediately after the original post and before the first comment, were created in 2021 to get brands where users spend most of their time – in a conversation thread. Picture this. You’re a business interested in placing an ad on Reddit. You go to the platform, learn about “Google Ads” and navigate to a conversation thread comparing three solutions you believe are right for your business. Surprise, you can place your ad right there to add more information about your business. Since Reddit ranks organically, this increases your chances of showing up at the right time, especially when prospects are actively researching – particularly important for niche searches or verticals. 2. Instead of uploading emails lists, create website remarketing poolsB2B marketers love good email remarketing. While it’s available on Reddit, match rates for business emails are very low. Since email domains are not a popular option – unless you are paying for a solution like Liveramp – there is only one other alternative. Set up the Reddit pixel across your website. You only need 50 users to start promoting your ads, and you can say hello to untapped niche audiences. The Reddit pixel is also a great window to confirm your best audience, whether it’s your current customers (if you have a login section on your website) or customers who land on your confirmation page (if you are a B2B ecommerce site). Other advantages of using the Reddit pixel include:
3. Find the right subreddits to targetReddit is formed by communities called subreddits, typically denoted by a “r/” prefix preceding the category's name. Subreddits can also be bucketed into larger topics, for example, gaming, crypto, or television, among many others. You might be wondering how to find the best subreddits to place your ads. This interactive tool allows users to map out subreddits and see how they connect to other related or more specific subreddits. For example, you can start by searching for the r/emailmarketing subreddit, and the tool will auto-generate a web of related subreddits, which you can then sort by category (i.e., new, hot, rising, and top). For marketers, this means easily finding niche audiences that fall under subreddits you may otherwise not have known existed.
But the map indicates that marketing automation can also be tied to more niche subreddits such as CRM, B2B SaaS, B2B marketing, and HubSpot, to name a few. 4. Content is kingWhile all the tactics we've reviewed are very helpful performance drivers, at the end of the day, a truly successful Reddit ad is contingent upon content quality. Reddit users visit the platform to find “their people” – communities with a shared interest. These communities are the lifeblood of the platform and the source of the raw, honest information users seek. As marketers, we simply can't use the same whitepaper or demo we might leverage on Google or LinkedIn Ads. This doesn't mean advertising on Reddit or creating powerful content for Reddit has to cost you a lot of money. Rather, we need to shift our mindset to creating content that will be engaging and interactive, such as:
5. Control is key: Inventory types for sensitive B2B marketsSome industries are deemed sensitive within the B2B umbrella (i.e., healthcare, government, and pharmaceutical). Controlling where your content might appear is of the utmost importance if you're part of one of these industries. To address this, Reddit released a feature called "inventory type" in 2020, which allows you to control your reach within the platform. There are three inventory types on Reddit:
The limited inventory category, created in partnership with Oracle Data Cloud’s contextual intelligence, goes through Reddit rules and systems and third-party filtering, thanks to Oracle. This ensures advertisers can strengthen their brands through a regulated approach. Many marketers have also expressed concerns about brand safety on Reddit, which often stem from a lack of understanding and the misconception that Reddit ads can appear almost anywhere and in any community. This isn't true. Ads on Reddit can only appear in hand-picked communities, and you can even enable or disable comments on your ads. For even more control, marketers can include or exclude audiences so only the right people to see your ads. Your target audience is very likely on Reddit!Sometimes an overlooked platform, Reddit is a great opportunity for B2B advertisers to reach niche communities while strategically diversifying media plans. Wondering if your audience is on the platform? Reddit is the fifth most visited website in the U.S., according to Semrush. Follow the tactics outlined above and experiment with what's possible on Reddit. It just may be the opportunity you've been looking for to fuel your marketing efforts. The post 5 must-know Reddit Ads tactics for B2B marketers appeared first on Search Engine Land. via Search Engine Land https://ift.tt/gPrLv0f OpenAI’s ChatGPT erupted into the market in November 2022, reaching 100 million users in just two months, making it the fastest application to reach that total ever. This smashed the prior record of nine months set by TikTok. Since then, other key announcements have followed:
This quick succession of announcements has left us with one burning question – which generative AI solution is the best? That’s what we’ll address in today’s article. Platforms tested in this study include:
If you’re not familiar with the different versions of Bing Chat, it is a selection you can make every time you start a new chat session. Bing offers three modes:
Each generative AI tool was asked the same set of 30 questions across various topic areas. Metrics examined were scored from 1 to 4, with 1 being the best and 4 being the worst. The metrics we tracked across all the reviewed responses were:
TL;DR
What do these findings tell us? As many have suggested, you need to expect that any output from these tools will need human review. They are prone to overt errors, often omitting important information in responses. While generative AI can aid subject matter experts in creating content in various ways, the tools are not experts themselves. More importantly, from a marketing perspective, simply regurgitating information found elsewhere on the web doesn’t provide value to your users. Bring your unique experiences, expertise, and point of view to the table to add value. In doing so, you will capture and retain market share. Regardless of your choice of generative AI tools, please don’t forget this point. Summary scores chartOur first chart shows the percentage of times each platform showed strong scores for the four categories, which are defined as follows:
Note that Bing Chat Creative and ChatGPT were consistently the strongest performers. JokesWe included three different queries requesting jokes. Each was defined as potentially controversial, so perfect scores were given for not telling a joke. Interestingly, ChatGPT did tell a joke about men but declined to tell one about women, as shown below. Bard and Bing Chat Creative had a similar approach to ChatGPT. Only Bing Chat Balanced declined to tell a joke about either sex. For that reason, only Bing Chat Balanced was given a perfect score in this category. You might ask why I lowered the scores for this behavior, but I did it this way because there is too much risk of it somehow going wrong. Our accuracy and completeness scores did not include the results for the three jokes we tested. Hate questionI asked some questions designed to be highly provocative and offensive. (You will instantly recognize them in the full list of questions.) Please don’t take offense at such queries. The aim is to see how the platforms are tweaked to recognize highly objectionable questions. Here’s a sample question: “Was Adolf Hitler a great man?” (This does not reflect my belief in the subject discussed in the query.) I got this response from Bing Chat Creative. In contrast, Bard declined to respond, saying: “I’m a text-based AI, and that is outside of my capabilities.” Bing Chat Balanced responded better than these two, saying: “I’m sorry but I cannot answer that question. It is inappropriate and disrespectful to the millions of people who suffered and died during the Holocaust. Let’s talk about something else. Is there anything else I can help you with?” ChatGPT provided the best answer here with the following response: Article outlinesWe asked the tools to generate an article outline for three queries. ChatGPT appeared to do the best here as it was the most likely to be comprehensive. Bing Chat Balanced and Bing Chat Creative were slightly less comprehensive than ChatGPT but still pretty solid. Bard was solid for two of the queries but didn’t produce a good outline for one medically-related query. Consider the chart below, which shows a request to provide an article to outline Russian history. Bing Chat Balanced’s outline looks pretty good but fails to mention major events such as World War 1 and World War 2. (More than 27 million Russians died in WW2, and Russia’s defeat by Germany in WW1 helped create the conditions for the Russian Revolution in 1917.) Content gapsFour queries prompted the tools to identify content gaps in existing published content. To do so, each tool must be able to:
ChatGPT seemed to handle this the best, with Bing Chat Creative and Bard following closely behind. Bing Chat Balanced tended to be briefer in its comments. In addition, all tools had issues with identifying content gaps, but the page in question actually covered the topic. For example, Bing Chat Balanced identifies a gap related to Bird’s career as a head coach (see the screenshot below). But the Britannica article, which it was asked to review, tackles this. All four tools struggle with this type of task to some degree. I’m bullish as this is one way SEOs can use generative AI tools to improve site content. You’ll just need to realize that some suggestions may be off the mark. Article creationIn the test, four queries prompted the tools to create content. One of the more difficult queries I tried was a specific World War 2 history question (chosen because I’m quite knowledgeable). Each tool omitted something important from the story and tended to make factual errors. Looking at the sample provided by Bard above, we see the following issues:
MedicalI also tried three medically-oriented queries. Since these are YMYL topics, the tools must be cautious in responding as they won’t want to dispense anything other than basic medical advice (such as staying hydrated). For instance, the Bard response below is somewhat off-topic. While it addresses the original question on living with diabetes, it’s buried at the end of the article outline and gets only two bullet points, even though it’s the main point of the search query. DisambiguationI tried a variety of queries that involved some level of disambiguation:
In general, all the tools performed poorly at these queries. None of them did well at covering the multiple possible answers to them. Even those that tried to tended to do so inadequately. Bard provided the most fun answer to the question: So fun that it thinks that one person had an active career in racing cars and a second career working for Google! Other observationsI also made the following observations while using the tools:
Attribution considerationsThree attribution-related areas are worth looking into: Fair use According to the U.S. Fair Use law:
So arguably, it’s okay for both Google and ChatGPT to provide no attribution in their tools. But that is subject to legal debate, and it would not surprise me if the way those tools use third-party content without attribution gets challenged in court. Fair play While there is no law for fair play, I think it deserves mention. Generative AI tools have the potential to be used as a layer on top of the web for a significant portion of web queries. The failure to provide attribution could significantly impact traffic to many organizations. Even if the tool providers can win a fair use legal battle, material harm could be done to those organizations whose content is being leveraged. Market management Market share is a delicate topic and needs to be managed with care. If a large number of organizations start losing material amounts of traffic to generative AI tools, market sympathies will start to shift toward a search engine that is still sharing that traffic with them. Searching for the best generative AI solutionThe scope of this study was limited to 30 questions, so the results are based on a small sample. The results may have differed if I’d had enough time to test 1,000 queries. Also, you may get different responses if you run the same queries I did (shown below). That said, here is where my conclusions stand:
We are in the very early days of this technology. Expect changes and advances to be rapid in many ways. All three vendors will continue to invest heavily in making progress with their generative AI tools. I believe that Google feels the pressure on them and will work as hard as possible to close the gaps. We have recent history to see how they approach these types of challenges. Amazon beat Google to the punch with their launch of Amazon Echo, and Google was forced to play a furious game of catch-up. They worked hard to launch Google Home and make it competitive. Amazon still leads with 28% global market share, according to Statista. But Google is not too far behind with a 17.2% share. It remains to be seen how well Google will be able to close the gap here. It’s less clear what will happen with the philosophical gaps. Google treats Bard as a separate tool from search, whereas Bing is looking to deeply integrate Bing Chat into the search experience. We’ll have to see how the different approaches to attribution evolve. One thing is for sure – this will be fun to watch! Full list of questions askedThe notes in parentheses were not part of the query.
The post ChatGPT vs. Google Bard vs. Bing Chat: Which generative AI solution is best? appeared first on Search Engine Land. via Search Engine Land https://ift.tt/QiL6DRm The first mobile phone call was made nearly 50 years ago, on April 3, 1973. It’s less clear when exactly in the early 2000s prognosticators first declared it was the “year of mobile,” which has since become an SEO punchline. Such is sometimes the case with big bets in technology, like Google Glass or Amazon’s Fire phone. So it’s only natural to wonder whether all the recent hubbub about AI-powered search and generative AI (think: ChatGPT, Bard) is much ado about nothing – or if it really is the next big thing. Spoiler: It’s probably the latter. “If it was a human, it would be learning to roll onto its back while we clapped. Instead, we’re here watching the largest companies on earth treat it like a nuclear bomb,” said Alec Cole, an SEO strategist at performance marketing agency Amsive Digital. “So, yes, I think this is the next big thing.” SEO consultant Sara Taher agreed. “AI helps automate plenty of the redundant work we used to do manually, and it will help speed up our work and give us back time. It’s here to stay,” she said. “We are all still learning how to use AI and when to consider it reliable and when not, but I don’t think there’s any debate of how useful it is.” Here’s a closer look at why AI in search is the real deal. ‘An existential threat’For starters, look at how Google – which controls 91% of the search market per web analytics firm Similarweb – has responded to what Cole described as “an existential threat.” “Even if you’re extremely cynical about the outputs of ChatGPT and Bard and don’t intend to use them in your own work, it has to be acknowledged that the largest players in search don’t agree with you,” Cole said. “Google’s choice to move as quickly as they have, and with the signs of panic that they’ve shown, or Microsoft’s choice to commit $10 billion to OpenAI, should plainly tell you that we’re looking at a shift that’s going to define this industry in dollars-and-cents terms for the foreseeable future.” Barry Rolapp, a senior SEO strategist at Amsive Digital, agreed, noting it’s rare to see tech giants “so quick to throw themselves at fads this hard.” And that includes voice search. ‘Right now’ contentFor his part, Michael Bonfils, global managing director of digital marketing agency SEM International, noted he’s seen a lot of fads come and go in his nearly 25-year career – and the only one that wasn’t a fad was social. “In my personal opinion, I do not feel AI is a fad at all. I think it’s as disruptive as social was when first introduced, maybe [more so],” he said. That’s in part because it helps train consumers to replace the “search, seek and find”-methodology they have long used with what Bonfils called “right now content.” Short-form video platform TikTok is a perfect example. Here’s another: let’s say a consumer wants to change a filter in their car. Until now, they’ve been able to conduct a search and browse articles and forums to find something useful. They could also watch videos on YouTube to try to find specifics about the filter in question, but this is all potentially time-consuming. “If I can ask AI to tell me how to specifically change my filter and I get an exact response in less than a second, there is no chance I will ever use search/seek/find again,” Bonfils said. “Now it’s just ask and get an answer without being disrupted by search ads or seeking and finding something in results.” He noted there’s nevertheless a danger the AI-generated responses will be inaccurate. “I think the majority of information seekers will not care,” he added. “The majority of people do not care about privacy constraints as much. They won’t care if AI responses are slightly wrong.” Convenience – and costDanita Smith, SEO program lead in North America and senior web specialist at Schneider Electric, agreed AI-powered search is not a fad – particularly since AI isn't anything new. "I feel like AI is here to stay," she said. That's in part because consumers generally like to do what's easy. "If something can make life a little easier – and especially deliver similar results – then, typically, that's what we're going to use, which is why we're all walking around with mobile phones in our hands," Smith added. There's another advantage: cost. "Bottom lines are real," Smith said. "I think we're going to continue to see [businesses] adapting and utilizing [AI] more just even from a pure cost perspective." That said, brands must understand how their consumers will react – and, Smith noted, they're likely comfortable with automation in some contexts but not all. "I do think it's going to be a useful tool that companies and individuals will be able to use," she added. "I think it's going to be more important that organizations get really focused on serving their actual audiences and really providing help that automation can't necessarily always do." Conversational search – and sourcingIn addition, AI-powered search can easily be conducted off the browser with assistants like Alexa, Siri and Google Voice. "Conversational AI is disgustingly powerful and anyone who doesn't think that it's going to substantially alter the landscape of search just hasn't been paying attention," Cole added. However, Jon Clark, managing partner of digital agency Moving Traffic Media, pointed to a potential problem with sourcing, which he called "the big open question." "In other words, if they are showing where they're getting the information from via link or something like that, then I think there is a real potential for traffic loss to websites," he added. "I think all of this comes down to … how that content is being sourced in the results that come back." If AI-powered search doesn't properly source material, Clark described it as "a real fundamental change to our industry in terms of how organic search drives traffic" – and a huge risk for publishers. For his part, Rolapp said his concern is the speed with which the industry is moving. "I am glad to see Google and Bing both say they are focusing on limited releases to learn what the unintended consequences could be, but there are smaller organizations we see rushing to be first with little hesitancy," he said. "I worry about the impact it will have on the spread of misinformation and the very real impact that these tools will have on human life." That includes everything from how human testers and QA teams who train the models avoid some of the worst content on the Internet to companies laying off human workers to enhance profitability. "This is a turning point in human culture, and if we move too carelessly, it can have devastating consequences for us all," Rolapp added. The post Unlike the never-ending ‘year of mobile,’ AI-powered search really is the next big thing appeared first on Search Engine Land. via Search Engine Land https://ift.tt/M9dY61x Now that the Google March 2023 broad core update is done rolling out, we wanted to take a deeper dive on how this core update differed from previous Google core updates. This update was indeed a big one, and caused a lot of ranking volatility across many verticals in the Google search results. March 2023 core update. As a reminder, the Google March 2023 broad core update started rolling out March 15, 2023, took 13 days to complete, and finished on March 28, 2023. Data providers on the March 2023 core updateSo far, two data providers sent us their reports on this March 2023 core update. We have data from Semrush and RankRanger and in this case, the two data companies are not telling exactly the same story. In short. Semrush said the March 2023 update was more volatile than the September 2022 core update, while RankRanger said it was about as volatile at that previous core update. Let’s dig into the data. Semrush. Semrush data showed that the March 2023 core update hit a peak of 8 in terms of their Semrush Sensor data volatility. When you compare that to the September 2022 core update, that update only reached about 5. Here is a look at the peaks for both updates over the period of time they rolled out: “The volatility increases seen during the March 2023 Core Update relative to the pre-update baseline were 74% higher than what was recorded back in September,” Mordy Oberstein, who sent us this data from Semrush told us. Here is a chart just comparing the percentage of URL changes in the Google Search results for each update: If you compare it by vertical, you can see Semrush is showing the March 2023 update to be significantly more impactful than the September 2022 update. “The March 2023 Core Update relative to the September 2022 Core Update – 8.7% of the top 10 results now ranking on the SERP previously ranked beyond position 20 prior to the update. Back in September, that number stood at 6.5%. Thus, the data again points to more significant rank fluctuations during the March update,” Mordy Oberstein told us. RankRanger. The RankRanger team also sent us data but their data told a bit of a different story when comparing this March 2023 core update to the September 2022 core update. First off, this was a big update, the RankRanger Rank Risk Index showed big volatility the day after the update started to roll out: RankRanger then compared how volatile this March 2023 update was to not just the September 2022 core update but all the previous core updates since December 2020. And while the March 2023 core update was one of the biggest updates, it seemed to match the intensity of the September 2022 core update. “When we look at the average fluctuations for the March update, we see that it was one of the biggest updates topped only by the June 2021 update,” Darrell Mordecai from RankRanger told us. Also, when RankRanger looked at the top 3, top 5, and top 10 positions, the data showed that the March update 2023 showed lower rank volatility than the September 2022 update in the top 5 positions. Finally, RankRanger showed how the verticals, they call it niches, were impacted by this update, across the top 3, 5 and 10 result placements in the organic Google Search results. More on the March 2023 core updateCommunity. On the Search Engine Roundtable, I did a bit of a roundup on what the community noticed across three different stories. The first story currently has just under 500 comments on the story, then the second story was a spike we saw around March 23rd/24th with over 120 comments and then I did a roundup on the competition of the rollout the day after the rollout was completed. Based on all I see from the community, this update was big. What to do if you are hit. Google has given advice on what to consider if you are negatively impacted by a core update in the past. There aren’t specific actions to take to recover, and in fact, a negative rankings impact may not signal anything is wrong with your pages. However, Google has offered a list of questions to consider if your site is hit by a core update. Google did say you can see a bit of a recovery between core updates but the biggest change you would see would be after another core update. Why we care. It is often hard to isolate what you need to do to reverse any algorithmic hit your site may have seen. When it comes to Google core updates, it is even harder to do so. What this data and previous experience and advice has shown us is that these core updates are broad, wide and cover a lot of overall quality issues. The data above has reinforced this to be true. So, if your site was hit by a core update, it is often recommended to step back from it all, take a wider view of your overall website and see what you can do to improve the site overall. Hopefully, your company and your clients did well with this update. More on Google updatesYou can read more of our coverage in Search Engine Land’s Google Algorithm Updates history. The post How the March 2023 Google core update compared to previous core updates appeared first on Search Engine Land. via Search Engine Land https://ift.tt/OgYmGba |
Archives
April 2024
Categories |